Alcoholism: Disease or Choice?

Young adults also have some of the lowest rates of treatment engagement for alcohol-related problems. Most people who meet the clinical criteria for an alcohol or other drug use disorder achieve full recovery, data show. Perhaps the most interesting proof of the curability of addiction came from a natural experiment, when soldiers returned home to America from Vietnam, where heroin use and addiction were widespread, affecting 15 to 35 percent of enlisted men. Heroin use was so common that soldiers were required to be tested for heroin addiction before being allowed to depart Vietnam. And the prefrontal cortex, the area of the brain responsible for rational decision-making, judgment, and control of behavior gets weakened, its connections to other parts of the brain pruned away.

The process of addiction is set in motion automatically, by the brain’s response to a behavior repeated often enough because it is reinforced by the very pleasurable—but, alas, short-lasting—reward of dopamine surge. What starts out as a voluntary choice gets quickly encoded in the neural circuity and relegated to automatic processes that leave little room for conscious control. Once seen as a moral failure, addiction has more recently been viewed strictly as a medical problem. The push to regard addiction as a disease is well-intentioned—driven by a desire to lessen stigma—but fails to account for the many facets and facts of the condition. Worse, it robs sufferers of the sense that they can overcome the problem with courage, creativity, and some hard work.

The brain becomes accustomed to the presence of alcohol, and a physical tolerance is developed over time. This simply means that a person must drink more in order to feel the desired effects (which, in the case of the alcoholic, are typically drunkenness). When tolerance develops a person starts to experience symptoms of alcohol withdrawal when they attempt to quit on their own. They might have a pounding headache because of dehydration, and experience changes to mood and behavior as a direct result.

Achieve lasting recovery

In the past, addiction was misunderstood because it’s a disease that many people exposed to alcohol never develop. People assumed that those with alcohol use disorders chose to keep drinking. To rephrase the question, “Is being a drinker so important to your identity that you are willing to risk future serious consequences just to be able to drink? ” If the answer is yes, then understanding the psychology behind that decision is vital to the well-being of that individual. We need to know why because it’s a high-stakes wager for those with a history of problems. If alcohol-related consequences have already piled up, one more mishap can be life-altering.

Is Addiction a Disease?

Thus, for both legal and illegal drugs some addicts conform to the expectations of the “chronic disease” label. However, as noted below, the correlates of quitting drugs are the correlates of decision making, not the correlates of the diseases addiction is said to be similar to. Figure 1 shows the cumulative frequency of remission as a function of the onset of dependence in a nation-wide representative sample of addicts (United States, Lopez-Quintero et al., 2011). The researchers first recruited a sample of more than 42,000 individuals whose demographic characteristics approximated those of the US population for individuals between the ages of 18 and 64 (Grant and Dawson, 2006). The participants were interviewed according to a questionnaire designed to produce an APA diagnosis when warranted. For those who currently or in the past met the criteria for “substance dependence” (the APA’s term for addiction), there were additional questions aimed at documenting the time course of clinically significant levels of drug use.

My Account

Researchers call these alcohol-free intervals “temporary alcohol abstinence challenges,” or TAACs. Research from international contexts, primarily in the United Kingdom and Australia, has found that TAAC participants may be motivated by concerns about the effects of alcohol on their health. Many of these TAAC participants report benefits, such as positive effects on sleep, weight, and self-rated health, and reduced levels of alcohol consumption following a TAAC. «There’s plenty of solid observational data showing a link between moderate drinking and a lower risk for heart disease and a tendency to live longer compared with people who don’t drink,» he says. American Treatment Network is an outpatient substance abuse clinic headquartered in Havertown, Pennsylvania. Our philosophy is customized integrated health care for our patient’s physical and behavioral needs in one central location and provides the follow up support necessary to beat opioid and alcohol addiction.

The DSM-III (Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders)

The report found no firm evidence that moderate drinking affects weight gain or cognitive decline. It also concluded that compared with never consuming alcohol, moderate drinking was linked with a lower risk of heart attack, stroke, and death from heart disease. Then in December 2024, a report from the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine gave a conflicting answer. It reviewed scientific evidence on the relationship between moderate alcohol consumption and health outcomes. The disease model has helped us understand alcoholism and develop drugs for the condition, Salloum said. «We tend to look at smaller and smaller parts of the human body, and the human mind and the human brain,» to find the cause of something, Young said.

  • Young adults also have some of the lowest rates of treatment engagement for alcohol-related problems.
  • Past research has shown that young adults often engage in high-risk drinking behaviors, such as binge drinking.
  • Because addiction is such a complex phenomenon, there are many theories about what addiction is.
  • Just as information from the American Medical Association gave credence to alcoholism as a disorder, a 1980 publication by the American Psychiatric Association (APA) identified substance abuse disorder as a mental health disorder.
  • While some people can maintain control over their addiction for a short period, any alcohol exposure could potentially cause a relapse.

At the same time, a new understanding of the downsides of food processing has cast whole milk in a more positive light. “I think consumers are starting to become more aware of nutrition labels, and they are looking for items that are less processed and have more protein,” Peña said. Though American schools have been required to serve skim and low-fat milk since 2012, several federal bills have been introduced to return whole milk to school cafeteria offerings. Other experts point out that the problem of disease stigmatization or identity crisis is not unique to alcoholism.

Notably, the DSM-III-R moved elements from the abuse category into the dependence category, recognizing that people could become physiologically dependent on substances without abusing substances. This lent more credence to the idea that substance abuse/dependence wasn’t cut and dry between physical and behavioral. There was much growing medical research at the time about how the physiological and behavioral aspects of alcohol dependence in combination could better define the disorder. Alcoholism, also known as alcohol addiction, is a chronic disease of the brain that’s characterized by compulsive decision-making, impulsive behavior and relapse. It’s triggered by genetic and environmental factors, and it causes biological changes in the brain that make abstaining from alcohol nearly impossible without medical treatment. The study authors concluded that both the SC movement and TAACs have the potential to engage young adults who want to stop or reduce their alcohol consumption.

MeSH terms

His pioneering work in treating alcoholics and advising the founders of Alcoholic Anonymous was directly responsible for transforming the way the medical community viewed alcoholism. Seeing addiction as a disease can make individuals feel hopeless about change and helpless, with no possibility of control over their own behavior. That doesn’t mean it is easy to gain control of the behaviors involved in addiction—but it is possible, and people do it every day. The disease model of addiction also suggests to people that they existing in a fragile state of recovery forever, always in danger of failing. The first of the seven chapters provides an overview of the history of drug use and abuse, as well as information about its current prevalence.

Since alcohol was first introduced to American culture, people have struggled with alcohol misuse and dependence. People have also grappled with the “great debate” for years and years  – is alcoholism a disease or a choice? Those who struggled with alcohol misuse and dependence were considered weak moral character, lacking willpower, or even psychologically unhinged. In fact, people who struggled with alcoholism used to be locked away in psychiatric hospitals, and many is alcoholism a choice were written off as incurably insane. It wasn’t until recently that medical professionals, scientists, and addiction specialists began to understand addiction as a disease — a chronic condition of the mind that could be effectively treated, but never entirely cured. Despite widespread recognition of the Disease Model of Addiction, many people still believe that alcoholism is a choice.

  • He notes, for example, that there is a genetic association for religious choice between identical twins reared apart (Waller, Kojetin, Bouchard, Lykken, & Tellegen, 1990).
  • Many people say that you can never become an alcoholic if you choose to never drink alcohol.
  • Often the problem of returning to alcohol is related to inflexible thinking.
  • Abuse, mental illness, spousal pressure, and divorce can be factors that contribute to estrangement, but two other key drivers should also be acknowledged.

It disrupts a person’s ability to think critically, make rational decisions and function normally. Major medical agencies and organizations disagree about which diseases are considered chronic, according to a 2016 article published in the journal Frontiers in Public Health. Many people say that you can never become an alcoholic if you choose to never drink alcohol. Although this is a cognitive-behavioral approach, it is combined with a commitment to abstinence.

“There may be some protective effects of whole-fat dairy against type 2 diabetes and cardiovascular disease,” family dietitian Qianzhi Zhang, PhD, RD, told Health. However, she noted that more well-designed long-term studies are needed to fully understand the role of whole-fat dairy in developing these conditions. Young said he is not advocating eliminating the disease model, but hopes instead to move beyond it. The medical community should find away to frame the condition so it is less threatening to people’s identify, perhaps by using different words to describe it, Young said.

Deja un comentario

Tu dirección de correo electrónico no será publicada. Los campos obligatorios están marcados con *